An eyewitness testimony is a statement given under oath by a person present at an event who can describe what happened. Child witnesses in court innocence lost frontline pbs. Attempts to prosecute cases of physical or sexual abuse, in which the child involved may be the only witness, have brought to the fore issues pertaining to the accuracy and reliability of their testimony. Children testifying in court are perceived to be more honest than adults, but their limited memory, communication skills, and greater suggestibility may make them less reliable witnesses than adults. Ensuring childrens accurate disclosure and memory is at the heart of the modern scientific study of childrens testimony. When expert testimony on the suggestibility of children is offered, the court must consider whether the research the expert will discuss sufficiently fits the facts of the case to be helpful to the jury. Much of the research derives from legal cases in which children provide crucial eyewitness evidence. Read the suggestibility of childrens recollections. Children s testimony is often the only evidence of alleged abuse. Memory and suggestibility in the forensic interview. Adults impact on the reliability and suggestibility of. This book examines childrens testimony from several perspectives and gives you insightful suggestions for increasing childrens abilities to testify accurately about traumatic things that have. Toglia an interactive approach to assessing the suggestibility and testimony of eyewitnesses marc lindberg commentary. On stress and accuracy in research on children s testimony gail s.
The influence of stress and arousal on the child witness douglas p. The next day, the teacher showed the children a torn book and a soiled teddy. Children are more suggestible than adults and younger children are more suggestible than older children. Inaccuracies in childrens testimony combines the literature on obedience to authority with that on suggestibility to create a third literature.
Legal rulings on the admissibility of childrens testimony reflect these long standing assumptions about children. The findings are at times contradictory and confusing, but several consistent results are appearing. Lets not exaggerate the suggestibility of children american. The suggestibility of childrens recollections book, 1991.
Memory and suggestibility in the forensic interview by. Amye warrenleubecker preschool children s susceptibility to memory impairment maria s. New era of skepticism regarding childrens credibility. Save time and improve your marks with cite this for me. An interactive approach to assessing the suggestibility and testimony of eyewitnesses marc lindberg. Legal rulings on the admissibility of childrens testimony reflect these longstanding assumptions about children.
The studies on which this conclusion was based were criticized on several grounds e. This book examines children s testimony from several perspectives and gives you insightful suggestions for increasing children s abilities to testify accurately about traumatic things that have. In international perspectives on child abuse and children s testimony. This book examines children s testimony from several perspectives and gives you insightful suggestions for increasing children s abilities to testify accurately about traumatic things that have happened to them. Nevertheless there is a critical need for uptodate research on the reliability of childrens testimony. Excerpt our goals in developing this book were straightforward. Written by a collection of leading scholars, memory and suggestibility in the forensic interview provides authoritative coverage of a topic that is both timely and important. Read the new book the suggestibility of children s recollections. We examine issues in memory recall and recognition and consider the effects of leading questions on children s testimony together with the conditions under which their answers gain. Payment socialscientistsand legalpractitionershavelong suspected thatsuggestiveforensic interview practices are a major cause of inaccuracies in eyewitness testimony. Suggestibility is the quality of being inclined to accept and act on the suggestions of others.
However, it wasnt until elizabeth loftuspublished a highly influential series of. The complex nature of these charges is often compounded by a lack of physical evidence or delay between the. Memory and suggestibility in the forensic interview will be a crucial resource for anyone involved in elucidating, interpreting, and reporting the memories of others. Part i of this article briefly describes the history and current state of research into children s suggestibility. The aim of the study was to determine the influence of authority on the susceptibility of child witnesses and the reliability of their testimonies. Expert testimony on the suggestibility of children. Memory, suggestibility, and eyewitness testimony in. This study, consisting of experimental and control groups, included 20 girls and 20 boys, totalling 40 children. Visit the apa books homepage to browse or search for other books. I highly recommend this authoritative book to anyone interested in memory and its relation to the law. The suggestibility of the child witness has been a concern of the american judicial. Visit the apa books homepage to browse or search for.
The multidisciplinary research, the first of its kind to examine judges perceptions of child witnesses, was led by queens university child and. Proper interviewing techniques must be utilized to safeguard childrens testimony from the effect of misinformation and suggestibility, as these could lead to false reports. Since the 1980s, that assumption has been buttressed by numerous studies that detected declines in false memory between early childhood and young adulthood under controlled conditions. This book examines childrens testimony from several perspectives and gives you insightful suggestions for increasing childrens abilities to testify accurately about traumatic things that have happened to them. The childrens answers when subjected to both of the manipulations were definitely impaired by this outside influence. Studies reveal suggestibility of very young as witnesses the. In this part, we argue that, although psychological researchers disagree considerably over the degree to which the suggestibility of young children may lead to false allegations of sexual abuse, there is an overwhelming consensus that. Children as eyewitnesses memory, suggestibility, and. Inaccuracies in childrens testimony haworth criminal. Judicial assessment of the credibility of child witnesses. Leading psychologists in the field address issues relevant to the reliability of childrens testimony. Reliability of children s eyewitness testimony psychology bibliographies in harvard style.
Fiftyfive percent of the children pointed to the genitalanal area on the dolls, even when they had not received any form of genital exam. These findings suggest that suggestibility effects reflect young children s susceptibility to serious memory errors, namely the tendency to believe they remembered seeing details that were only suggested to them. It deals with several highly publicized cases which were based on children s testimony this is an often fascinating book. In gainsaying children s testimony a valid response to their inferior memories and greater suggestibility proneness. Therefore, children should not be used in courtroom testimony, especially younger preschoolers. Suggestibility of childrens memory the interaction. Original event misleading information eyewitness testimony misinformation.
Childrens testimony wiley online books wiley online library. In summary, there has been a proliferation of studies on the suggestibility of children s memories. Inaccuracies in children s testimony combines the literature on obedience to authority with that on suggestibility to create a third literature. Although the historical literature on children s suggestibility, with only.
Memory, suggestibility, and eyewitness testimony in children and adults. A hoary assumption of the law is that children are more prone to falsememory reports than adults, and hence, their testimony is less reliable than adults. Ever since loftus published her first studies on the suggestibility of eyewitness testimony in the 1970s, social scientists, police. Definitions of suggestibility traditional definition.
Thus, the importance of conducting forensic interviews that are free from bias and misleading information is immense, as these could lead to false reports. Although children are perceived as more likely than adults to make errors in their testimony due to limitations of memory and communication skills, as well due to the greater suggestibility of children, judges perceive children as more honest than adults. The testimony of small children has usually been considered truthful. During circumstances in which a child is a witness to the event, the child can be used to deliver a testimony on the stand. The testimony of the childs aunt evelyn and her grandmother who both testified for the defense as to the events subsequent to the alleged abuse was consistent with the childs. One may fill in gaps in certain memories with false information given by another when recalling a scenario or moment. Children are often legally competent to give eyewitness testimony. Children s memory and suggestibility allegations of child physical abuse and child sexual abuse are serious matters requiring skillful, methodical investigation.
Children may be called upon to bear witness to such crimes as murder, domestic violence, kidnapping, robbery, and more. When expert testimony on the suggestibility of children is offered, the court. Formerly, studies in this area indicated that there were pronounced agerelated differences in suggestibility, with preschool children being particularly susceptible to misleading suggestions. In this part, we argue that, although psychological researchers disagree considerably over the degree to which the suggestibility of young children may lead to false allegations of sexual abuse, there is an overwhelming consensus that children are suggestible to a degree that, we. We discuss the development of the book suggestibility scale for children bssc, a twofactor suggestibility measure developed as an alternative to the video suggestibility scale for children.
948 1042 659 1397 537 751 64 740 571 1144 565 478 42 573 1161 817 1544 231 661 996 1270 1375 1234 521 1390 1312 475 183 1272 1250 1028 712 1552 83 566 1159 1379 1362 1152 306 261 394 1049 422